A styled flat-lay of colorful, hand-painted cookies on a light beige background with soft leaf shadows. The cookies feature various designs, including a central rectangular cookie with 'THINKING OF YOU' in rainbow lettering, several paint palettes with multicolored paint splatters, and two small blue paintbrushes next to a small white dish of white paint.

PRE-DESIGNED, PERSONALIZED & PYO

Cookies without the planning
Skip to results list
7 items

Filter

  • A rectangular white product, likely a small plaque, coaster, or decorative tile, featuring a black line art drawing of a birthday cake and banner that reads 'HAPPY B-DAY'. Above the illustration are four colored squares in red, yellow, blue, and purple.

    Birthday Cake Paint Your Own Cookie

    Birthday Cake Paint Your Own Cookie
    $7.10
  • Crafty Cookiers Gift Card

    Crafty Cookiers Gift Card

    Crafty Cookiers Gift Card
    $50.00
  • A clear cellophane gift bag tied with a beige ribbon, containing a small camera-shaped keepsake with a printed baby photo on the screen and pink floral accents, photographed on a light gray background.

    Custom Camera Cookie With Photo

    Custom Camera Cookie With Photo
    $7.54
  • A rectangular sugar cookie decorated with a custom watercolor portrait of a couple, featuring four watercolor paint swatches at the top (red, purple, blue, green) and a hand-painted illustration of a man in a pink shirt and a woman in a blue floral top. The cookie is photographed on a white surface next to a paintbrush and paper towel.

    Custom Paint Your Own Cookie

    Custom Paint Your Own Cookie
    $7.63
  • A square white-frosted cookie with the words 'THANK YOU!' written in large, colorful rainbow letters, shown on a plain white background.

    Large Thank You Cookie

    Large Thank You Cookie
    $5.45
  • A square white-frosted cookie with the words 'THANK YOU!' written in large, colorful rainbow letters, shown on a plain white background.

    Mini Thank You Cookie

    Mini Thank You Cookie
    $3.27
  • November Cookie Club

    November Cookie Club

    November Cookie Club
    $32.70
Or Learn About Our Monthly Cookie Club →

CRAFTY COOKIERS SPECIALIZES IN CUSTOM ORDERS

Looking for something made just for you?

Our Cookie Shop is filled with ready-to-order favourites, but we also take on custom cookie orders for birthdays, weddings, corporate events, showers, celebrations, and everything in between. Have an idea in mind? Send us the details and let’s see what we can create.

A minimalist graphic icon featuring a black hand-drawn heart outline over a solid teal-green abstract shape, set against a plain white background.

Thank Yous

A simple line-art illustration of a birthday cake with a single lit candle, shown on a white background with a pale yellow circular backdrop.

Birthdays

A stylized gift box illustration with a white body, black outlines, blue-purple splash shapes behind it, and small black star accents.

Corporate Gifts

A simple line-art illustration of a party hat with black outlines, a teal fill, and small black stars, shown on a plain white background.

Celebrations

A stylized yellow flower icon with black outlines on a white background.

Just Because

Inquire About Custom Cookies →
Photo from – Payal .S

“Crafty Cookiers is amazing! Alicia has made many paint your own cookies for both my son’s birthday party favours + more! The designs are always amazing and on theme with the birthday invitation.”

— – Payal .S

Five individually wrapped square cookies decorated with moving-themed illustrations and a large 'THANK YOU!' message, arranged on a light wood surface.
A close-up of packaged triangular chocolate pieces on a blue patterned tray, with a blurred plate of colorful candies in the background.
A group of football-shaped sugar cookies decorated with brown icing, white laces, and white text reading 'EZEKIEL' and 'ONE YEAR DOWN' on a light gray background.
A tray of decorated Minnie Mouse-themed birthday cookies, including a number 1, Minnie Mouse silhouette cookies, polka dot bows, and a rectangular 'Minnie' cookie, displayed on a pink tablecloth with party supplies in the background.