Join Our Cookie Club
A monthly box of handcrafted sugar cookies with seasonal themes, beautifully printed designs, and rotating flavours. No special occasion required.
Choose your box, subscribe once, and we’ll take care of the rest
Cookie Club is for the people who love treating themselves and their families to extra special cookies (bonus is you can stock your freezer with snack packs!). Each month brings a new flavour, new designs, and a new reason to open the box before you’ve even taken your coat off.
November Cookie Club
ONE-TIME PURCHASE OR SUBSCRIBE & SAVE
This month’s Cookie Club theme is Slow Sunday Season, featuring our Spiced Cookie Butter flavour. Ordering closes October 18. For local pickup orders, your box will be ready November 5 from 1–6 PM, following our regular first-Thursday-of-the-month pickup schedule.
Boxes are available on the first Thursday of each month. Choose free local pickup, $5 delivery within Saugeen Shores, or $15 Ontario-wide shipping.
Make your box a little extra.
Cookie Club members can add on favourites like Snack Packs and Paint Your Own cookies, with occasional exclusive extras depending on the month. Once you add your Cookie Club box to your cart, you’ll be able to see the available add-ons for that month and choose any extras you’d like to include.
And if you’re a monthly subscriber, the treats don’t stop there. You’ll unlock milestone perks along the way:
Milestone perks are added automatically when you reach each milestone, so there are no codes or extra steps to remember.
Keep an eye on each month’s collection to see what Alicia has dreamt up next.
Spiced Cookie Butter Flavour
All-purpose flour, Sugars (Granulated, Powdered, Corn syrup), Butter, Meringue powder (Corn starch, Dried egg-white, Sugar, Acacia gum, Calcium sulphate, Citric acid, Potassium acid tartrate, Artificial flavour, Silicon dioxide), Egg, Cornstarch, Vanilla extract, Food colouring dyes, Biscoff cookies, Biscoff spread.
Contains: egg, wheat, dairy. May Contain traces of any common allergy.
Cookie Club started as a way for Alicia to create more often, experiment with new ideas, and give you a reason to enjoy custom-style cookies even when you don’t have a birthday, wedding, or big event on the calendar.
She loves getting to create something different every month and hopes that opening your cookie box feels like opening a present each time.
01
Choose your box
Pick a Half Dozen or Full Dozen, then choose a one-time box or monthly subscription.
02
New collection every month
Each box features a fresh theme, beautifully printed designs, and a rotating flavour inspired by the season and whatever Alicia is excited to create next.
03
Look forward to the first Thursday
Boxes are available on the first Thursday of each month. Choose free local pickup, $5 delivery within Saugeen Shores, or $15 Ontario-wide shipping.
04
Always flexible
Monthly subscriptions are billed on the 20th and can be skipped or cancelled before your next renewal date.
What’s baking next?
Part of the fun is not knowing exactly what’s coming next.
Cookie Club collections are inspired by seasons, holidays, flavours, trends, and creative ideas Alicia can’t stop thinking about. Every month is designed as its own collection, so the cookies feel just as fun to open as they are to eat.
And because Crafty Cookiers specializes in printed sugar cookies, the designs can get incredibly detailed.
Something new every month
Fresh designs, rotating flavours, and seasonal collections
No last-minute ordering
Your next cookie box is already handled
Made in small batches
Handmade and packaged by Alicia in Port Elgin, Ontario.
Subscriber pricing
Enjoy special monthly pricing when you subscribe.
Really good cookies
Because looking amazing is only half the job.
Is our Cookie Club not quite what you're looking for? There are plenty of other ways to get your Crafty Cookiers fix:
New theme. New flavour. One very good reason to look forward to the first Thursday of the month.
See Some of Our Past Cookie Club Boxes:
October's Flavour: Pumpkin Spice Blondie
September Flavour: Apple Cider
August Flavour: Cookies & Cream
July Flavour: Maple Chocolate Chip
June Flavour: Strawberry Lemonade
1 / 5
Have questions? We're here to help.
The Cookie Shop features pre-designed cookies with a short baking turnaround time and seasonal releases you can purchase whenever available. Cookie Club is our monthly curated box with a fresh theme, rotating flavour, and subscriber pricing.
Cookie Club boxes are scheduled for the first Thursday of every month. If you need an alternative arrangement, reach out and we’ll see what can be accommodated.
Absolutely. Cookie Club makes a fun gift for anyone who loves having something sweet to look forward to.
Yes. Cookie Club subscriptions are flexible. Changes should be made before the monthly cutoff of the 20th.
Because Cookie Club boxes are made specifically for each monthly order, refunds aren’t generally offered. If there’s ever an issue with your order, please reach out so we can make it right.
No. Crafty Cookiers cookies are not made in a nut-free facility. Ingredient information is available on the applicable product pages.
Local delivery is available within Saugeen Shores. For addresses outside the local delivery area, Ontario-wide shipping is also available.
Yes. You can choose a one-time Cookie Club box at the regular price or subscribe monthly for subscriber pricing.
Choose a Half Dozen with 6 cookies or a Full Dozen with 12 cookies.
The Cookie Club box comes with either 6 or 12 large, thick-cut sugar cookies in the monthly flavour, along with any optional add-ons you selected.
You can add snack packs and Paint Your Own cookies to your box at any time. Depending on the month, additional add-ons may be available.
